Welcome to TVPaint Community forums !

The "redo" function in tvpaint could be better in my opinion.

When I use 'undo' then move one frame to the right and the I want to use 'redo', it doesn't work anymore. The 'redo' function shouldn't be affected by moving trough your timeline.

Perhaps you should try "Multi Redo" in the Keyboard Shortcuts panel > Undo. That's what I use and I don't have the problem you're describing.

Perhaps you should try "Multi Redo" in the Keyboard Shortcuts panel > Undo. That's what I use and I don't have the problem you're describing.

I'm using multi rede. But it doesn't work well (tvpaint 10, mac).
Try this: draw something > undo > move one frame right> redo : nothing happens....

I can't reproduce it.

I need more details. Please can you grab screenshots ?

Here is a screencapture:

[qt]1494,1072,http://joostlieuwma.nl/temp/screencapture2.mov[/qt]

Joost wrote: I'm using multi rede. But it doesn't work well (tvpaint 10, mac).
Try this: draw something > undo > move one frame right> redo : nothing happens....

But that's because you've started another action by moving to the next frame. Same happens when you draw something > undo then draw something else > redo; nothing happens. Unless I am misunderstanding you.

But if you want to apply what you've just drawn on the previous frame you should press enter (re-apply), this only works for the last stroke you've drawn though...

ok, it sounds like a bug (on all OS).

But that's because you've started another action by moving to the next frame

Yes, I understand that, but in my opinion moving to the next frame (or: moving trough your timeline) shouldn't be another action (when it comes to the 'redo' function). So that's why this is a feature request...

oppps : no : not a bug.

You just confused "redo" ([Shift + U] shortcut) and "reapply" ([enter] shortcut).

Joost wrote: Yes, I understand that, but in my opinion moving to the next frame (or: moving trough your timeline) shouldn't be another action (when it comes to the 'redo' function). So that's why this is a feature request...

Makes sense.

There is a similar Feature request here, where I have quoted this conversion
http://forum.tvpaint.com/viewtopic.php?f=21&t=8684


By the way Fabrice. Reading from this post it seems like you have misunderstood Joost's request

Fabrice wrote:oppps : no : not a bug.
You just confused "redo" ([Shift + U] shortcut) and "reapply" ([enter] shortcut).

By the way Fabrice. Reading from this post it seems like you have misunderstood Joost's request

Will read and check the whole undo/redo discussions when back in the office.
But it touch to "what is an action in TVPaint" , so it's deep in the code and any minor change can create random bugs.
So will see what is possible.