Page 2 of 2
Re: more logic behaviour when deleting the first frame(s) of a layer
Posted: 14 Nov 2020, 17:22
by Peter Wassink
but apart from doing this through the pull down menu
don't we also need a way to set behaviour when simply using the DEL key?
and i did not understand what you mean with: "keep empty"
- deleting frames.png (75.65 KiB) Viewed 17916 times
Re: more logic behaviour when deleting the first frame(s) of a layer
Posted: 14 Nov 2020, 17:42
by Peter Wassink
BTW.Happy that you are addressing this!
but apart from doing this through the pull down menu
won't we also need a way to set the behaviour when simply using the DEL key?
and can't you make it so that, when the first or last frame are part of the deleted selection, the remaining part always stays in place.
so we only need the options on a selection in the middle...
i propose naming it so its clear what part of the layer stays in place:
Fix Right
Fix Left
Pin Right
Pin Left
Hold Right
Hold Left
Keep Right
Keep Left
and i did not understand what you mean with: "keep empty" will that be filled with empty instances?
i think the option in my image above... is not possible in the current layer engine...
Re: more logic behaviour when deleting the first frame(s) of a layer
Posted: 14 Nov 2020, 18:58
by Paul Fierlinger
I see KEEP EMPTY as very useful when making room for a selected amount of new frames. I understand that we have INSERT frames but this KEEP EMPTY would allow us to first prepare the space for the new frames instead of having to first insert and only after seeing what this has caused (and there are times when I don't even spot right away what I have wrought)leaving us with a possible mess to start fixing with all sorts of workarounds.
What confuses me is the use of the word FIX which to me firstly means FIX something that has become broken. There are perhaps better expressions such as DEFINE, FASTEN, MAKE, PREPARE, SET, SPECIFY and even more....
Re: more logic behaviour when deleting the first frame(s) of a layer
Posted: 15 Nov 2020, 17:39
by Peter Wassink
Paul Fierlinger wrote: ↑14 Nov 2020, 18:58
What confuses me is the use of the word FIX which to me firstly means FIX something that has become broken...
i agree, it was ment as a short form for "Fixate"
Re: more logic behaviour when deleting the first frame(s) of a layer
Posted: 15 Nov 2020, 19:23
by Svengali
Here's my attempt at a muti-option Delete button...
- DeleteSelect.png (18.21 KiB) Viewed 17876 times
sven
Edit: updated DeleteSelect.tvpx to tweak error-trapping
Re: more logic behaviour when deleting the first frame(s) of a layer
Posted: 15 Nov 2020, 22:15
by Paul Fierlinger
It works very well for me; simple, straightforward and will get a lot of use out of this. Thanks!
Re: more logic behaviour when deleting the first frame(s) of a layer
Posted: 15 Nov 2020, 23:56
by Xavier
Peter Wassink wrote: ↑14 Nov 2020, 17:22
and i did not understand what you mean with: "keep empty"
Keep empty because so far I found no way to delete the cells without deleting the layer, but I could easily erase their content
Re: more logic behaviour when deleting the first frame(s) of a layer
Posted: 15 Nov 2020, 23:56
by Xavier
Svengali wrote: ↑15 Nov 2020, 19:23
Here's my attempt at a muti-option Delete button...
DeleteSelect.png
sven
Edit: updated DeleteSelect.tvpx to tweak error-trapping
Glad to notice that we came to the same conclusion ^^
Re: more logic behaviour when deleting the first frame(s) of a layer
Posted: 16 Nov 2020, 00:09
by Paul Fierlinger
To be able to keep empty frames can be very useful. Time and again I find the need to tighten a scene that I have already completed and I must replace a definite space with new frames. Often, during such revisions I have to do all that is made available in this shortcut: Replace old frames with redrawn new ones and tighten the frames from both ends to make a new perfect fit. Simply put, the empty frames become a placeholder for frames yet to be drawn.
Re: more logic behaviour when deleting the first frame(s) of a layer
Posted: 16 Nov 2020, 15:06
by Paul Fierlinger
OOPS
Re: more logic behaviour when deleting the first frame(s) of a layer
Posted: 16 Nov 2020, 18:13
by Xavier
Ah ! that's a question to ask in the "Technical support" ... or maybe in the beta forum
Re: more logic behaviour when deleting the first frame(s) of a layer
Posted: 17 Dec 2020, 14:20
by Xavier
Is the same behaviour applicable to the clip deletion ?
- delete_clip.png (90.78 KiB) Viewed 17393 times
Re: more logic behaviour when deleting the first frame(s) of a layer
Posted: 10 Jan 2021, 15:14
by shachamrr
Peter Wassink wrote: ↑28 Aug 2020, 16:46
When you are anywhere on the tail of a layer and you delete a selection of frames (or just one), the layer remains at its start position and the frames after the selection are shifted to the left.
so far so good.
My request is that when a selection of frames on a layer includes the first frame, deleting this selection, should leave the remaining frames at the position that they were
In by far the most cases i delete the first part of a layer to trim it to match other layers, meaning the rest of the layer should stay put.
Now, after deleting
begin frames, i always have to re-shift the remains back to where they were before.
the general logic in layer behaviour when deleting frames should be:
deleting frames lets the layer stay in position on the timeline
What do others think?
+1
Totally agreed, any workaround requires more clicks and isn't intuitive.
Re: more logic behaviour when deleting the first frame(s) of a layer
Posted: 10 Jan 2021, 16:44
by Paul Fierlinger
I'm with you on this one as well.