Anti Aliasing on Flood Fill Topic is solved

[Kramme]

I would love it if we could get an anti aliasing option for the fill tool.
I know there is one for the filled stroke tool, but it does not seem to make a big difference when I click it on.

[Mads Juul]

I would love it if we could get an anti aliasing option for the fill tool.

+1

[Mads Juul]

I know there is one for the filled stroke tool, but it does not seem to make a big difference when I click it on.

I confirm this bug in the Filled stroke tool. the antialiasing does not work.

With Antialising

filledstrokeWithAtiAliasing.JPG (86.81 KiB) Viewed 35956 times

Without Anti Aliasing

filledstrokeNoAtiAliasing.JPG (87.8 KiB) Viewed 35956 times

-Mads

[slowtiger]

What about checking "smooth" first? Try with a value of 1 or 2.

[Mads Juul]

What about checking "smooth" first? Try with a value of 1 or 2.

Personally I have tried the smooth option and I dont like it. I think it looks ugly.
Lets look at these 2 examples. the Tool : Filling Shape have both options Smooth and A Aliasing. So it is easy to compare.
First a filled shape with smooth.

fill_smooth.JPG (47.34 KiB) Viewed 35951 times

I think it looks jagged and ugly.



And then the same tool with a aliasing

fill_aaliasing.JPG (44.75 KiB) Viewed 35951 times

Here the edges look nice and crisp,So I would like to see the AAlising option on the Flood fill as well

-Mads

[Elodie]

You're right Mads. I'll report that to the developers.

[Mads Juul]

You're right Mads. I'll report that to the developers.

Thank You
Remember we have discussed 2 things
1) Anti Aliasing on Flood Fill
2) Anti Aliasing on Shape Fill Inside is not working

-Mads

[Elodie]

Thank you for resuming the 2 points, I was only about to report the second one

[Mads Juul]

Thank you for resuming the 2 points, I was only about to report the second one

Thank you.
And please notice The difference between using smooth and aaliasing,.
I think all will agree the aalising looks so much better than smooth.
This is why we would like aaliasing on the Flood fill to make it work better.
-mads

[Kramme]

I'll report that to the developers.

Thanks a lot

[Soom]

Wait - what? Was it fixed already? cause I just downloaded the TVPaint 10.5.3 upgrade, and the Filled Stroke AAliasing works just fine! I never knew how it worked before, as I never used it...

Thank you for resuming the 2 points, I was only about to report the second one

Thank you.
And please notice The difference between using smooth and aaliasing,.
I think all will agree the aalising looks so much better than smooth.
This is why we would like aaliasing on the Flood fill to make it work better.
-mads

Don't confuse - Smooth has a different intention - it's used to BLUR the edges of shapes, which is necessary in some cases.

[schwarzgrau]

yeah +1 for the flood fill, I always get jagged edges

[zacdyson]

Has anything happened with this? I want it desperately

[Elodie]

Not yet.

[schwarzgrau]

I'm sorry to stress this again, but it's really annoying to export my drawings layer by layer to fill them in Photoshop and export and import the fillings again in TVPaint.
Did someone find time to start working on this topic?